History Made in the NFL Draft: Abdul Carter Lands in the Top 5

The 2025 NFL Draft delivered a moment that will be remembered for years to come. With the third overall pick, the New York Giants selected Abdul Carter, an edge rusher from Penn State, and in doing so, made history. Carter became the first openly Muslim player ever drafted in the top 10, a groundbreaking achievement that resonated far beyond the football field. As the crowd erupted and Carter’s name flashed across the screen, it was clear: this was more than just a draft pick. It was a historic symbol of progress.

For organizations like the Fritz Pollard Alliance (FPA), which has long championed diversity and inclusion in the NFL, Carter’s selection is a testament to the strides being made. The FPA’s mission—to ensure equal opportunity for all, regardless of race, religion, or background—found a powerful new example in Carter’s rise. His journey to the top of the draft not only highlights his exceptional talent but also continues to advance a broader shift toward a more inclusive NFL, where players from all walks of life can thrive.

The Scarcity of Muslim Players in the NFL

Carter’s historic draft position stands out even more when viewed against the backdrop of Muslim representation in the NFL. The numbers tell a stark story: out of over 1,700 active roster spots, fewer than 20 players are estimated to identify as Muslim at any given time. Names like Aqib Talib, a former first-round pick, and brothers Husain and Hamza Abdullah come to mind, and perhaps the most prominent is Ahmad Rashad, who, as Bobby Moore, was drafted fourth overall in 1972. 

Rashad, one of the first Muslim athletes in any professional sport, helped put Muslim representation on the map in the 1970s, showing it was possible to excel at the highest levels. His illustrious career as a wide receiver, marked by four Pro Bowl selections, was followed by a high-profile role as a sportscaster, keeping him in the spotlight as a standout role model for younger generations.

But although there have been a handful of Muslim athletes who have excelled in the NFL, they remain exceptions in a league where Islamic athletes are rare. This scarcity isn’t surprising, however, when considering the broader context. Muslims make up just 1.1% of the U.S. population, and many come from communities where football may not be the primary sport or where access to elite training programs is limited. 

Additionally, Muslim players often face unique challenges, such as balancing religious practices with the demands of professional football. Fasting during Ramadan, for example, can overlap with training camps, requiring extraordinary discipline and resilience—qualities Carter has clearly demonstrated. These challenges only make Carter’s achievement more remarkable. 

Overcoming the Odds: Abdul Carter’s Journey to the Top

Abdul Carter’s rise to the No. 3 overall pick is a testament to his extraordinary talent and relentless work ethic. As an edge rusher at Penn State, Carter was a force to be reckoned with, known for his lightning-quick first step, powerful tackles, and ability to disrupt even the most seasoned offenses. His college career was decorated with accolades, including multiple All-American honors and a school-record 18 sacks in his final season. Scouts praised his versatility, noting his ability to play multiple positions along the defensive line, making him a nightmare for opposing quarterbacks.

But Carter’s journey wasn’t just about physical prowess. Behind the stats and highlights lies a story of determination. As a Muslim athlete, Carter navigated a path few have traveled, balancing his faith with the demands of elite competition. His success is a shining example of how diversity can enrich the game, bringing new perspectives and strengths to the field.

The Fritz Pollard Alliance has long advocated for creating opportunities for underrepresented groups to excel in the NFL, and Carter’s draft position is a reflection of that progress. Through initiatives like mentorship programs and diversity-focused events, the FPA has helped pave the way for players like Carter to reach their full potential, proving that talent knows no boundaries.

Inspiring Future Muslim Athletes to Excellence

Carter’s high-profile selection is more than just a personal triumph—it’s a source of inspiration for young Muslim athletes across the country. For many, seeing a player who shares their faith achieve such success in the NFL can ignite dreams that once seemed out of reach. Carter’s visibility as a Muslim player sends a powerful message: the NFL is a place where diversity is celebrated, and anyone with the talent and drive can succeed.

This moment echoes the broader impact of trailblazers in other underrepresented groups. Just as black quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes and Lamar Jackson have inspired a new generation of athletes at the NFL’s most high-profile position, Carter’s success has the potential to do similar things for Muslim youth. His story could encourage more young Muslims to pursue football, knowing that their faith and background do not have to be barriers, but rather, part of what makes them unique.

A Step Forward for Diversity in the NFL

Abdul Carter’s selection as the No. 3 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft is a milestone worth celebrating. It’s a historic moment for Muslim representation in the league and a powerful example of the progress being made toward a more inclusive NFL. For the Fritz Pollard Alliance, it’s another testament to the organization’s tireless work to break down barriers and create opportunities for all.

So, as we cheer for Carter in his rookie season and beyond, we’re not just rooting for a talented player—we’re rooting for a more diverse, inclusive NFL. And that’s a win for everyone.